Reach the Admissions Initiative (AI) via email:
For questions specifically related to submitting letters, please contact:
Letters of Evaluation Guidelines
View the Letters of Evaluation Guidelines in one of two format
Please note that letters should be not be submitted to the Admissions Initiative, but instead using the AMCAS Letter Writer Application.
Guidelines for Writing a Letter of Evaluation for a Medical School Applicant
The following guidelines aim to enhance the letter writing process in order to benefit both letter writers and admissions committees. They are organized into two sections that describe (1) tips about how to write a letter and (2) key areas of interest to medical schools.
How to use the guidelines
Please note that use of these guidelines is optional. They are intended to help you think about your letter and facilitate the writing process.
Medical schools do not expect any one letter writer to provide information about every characteristic of an applicant. In fact, they require multiple letters specifically because no one letter writer is expected to know everything about an applicant.
A Special Note to Writers of Committee Letters
Medical schools value committee letters because they provide an integrated and institutional perspective on an applicant’s readiness for medical school. They provide a comprehensive evaluation of applicants based on direct observation and the synthesis of information provided by faculty and others at an institution. This integrated perspective provides unique and valuable information about applicants.
While we recognize that many committee letters already incorporate the concepts included in these guidelines and key areas of interest, we believe that the material provided here can only complement the current committee letter process by enhancing its effectiveness. Those who work with individual letter writers can use these guidelines and key areas of interest as educational tools to encourage greater focus in individual letters. Writers of committee letters may also wish to re-fashion the overarching committee letter produced by their school to more closely reflect the central points provided here.
1. Provide an accurate assessment of the applicant’s suitability for medical school rather than advocate for the applicant.
2. Briefly explain your relationship with the applicant:
- How long you have known the applicant;
- In what capacity you have interacted (e.g., faculty, pre-medical advisor, supervisor, etc.); and
- Whether you are writing based on direct or indirect observations.
3. Quality is more important than letter length. Focus on the applicant rather than details about the lab, course, assignment, job, or institution.
4. Only include information on grades, GPA, or MCAT scores if you are providing context to help interpret them. Grades, GPA, and MCAT scores are available within the application.
5. Focus on behaviors that you have observed directly when describing applicants’ suitability for medical school. Consider describing:
- The situation or context of the behavior
- The actual behavior(s) you observed
- Any consequences of that behavior
6. Admissions committees find comparison information helpful. If you make comparisons, be sure to provide context. Include information about:
- The comparison group (e.g., students in a class you taught, students in your department, co-workers, etc.)
- Your rationale for the final comparison
Key Areas of Interest
A. Unique Contributions to the Incoming Class
- Describe obstacles that the applicant had to overcome, and if applicable, how those obstacles led to new learning and growth
- Explain how the applicant may contribute to a medical school’s diversity, broadly defined (e.g., background, attributes, experiences, etc.)
Note: If you write about any information that could be considered potentially sensitive, confirm with the applicant that s/he is comfortable with the inclusion of that information.
B. Core, Entry-level Competencies
Describe how the applicant has, or has not, demonstrated any of the following competencies that are necessary for success in medical school.
For more information on uploading letters, visit AMCAS Letter Resources.
Read the 2014 Survey of Letter Writer Reactions to the Letters Guidelines
2014 Survey of Letter Writers
The Admissions Initiative completed a survey on reactions to the Letters of Evaluation Guidelines
2014 Survey of Letter Writer Reactions to the Letters Guidelines
The AI advocates the implementation of holistic admissions