The
Ad Hoc Group's FY 2002 Proposal
Why Are We Doubling the NIH Budget
The Federal Government's
commitment to the National Institutes of Health (NIH) has
resulted in an explosion of knowledge that promises to advance
our ability to understand the biological basis of disease
and unlock new and effective strategies for disease prevention,
diagnosis, treatment and cures. As the 20th Century drew to
a close, the existence of these unparalleled scientific possibilities,
combined with a flourishing national economy, presented a
unique opportunity to accelerate and transform this nation's
medical research effort to address the continued health challenges
facing us.
Congress
responded by committing, in a bipartisan fashion, to double
the NIH budget over the five-year period FY 1999 to FY 2003.
The main reasons for continuing this doubling effort are discussed
in this section, and include the many health needs we still
face, the tremendous array of new scientific opportunities
for conquering these diseases presented by the post-genomic
era, and the large economic benefits to be derived from expected
improvements in health.
A.
Current Health Needs:
The
sustained federal commitment to medical research has produced
significant health benefits in the United States. However,
despite the progress that has been made against many diseases,
there remain critical challenges to the health of an aging
and increasingly diverse population. In addition, the increasing
frequency of international travel makes the United States
part of a global health community, which means that diseases
that emerge in foreign nations also are likely health threats
in this country. Several of these important health challenges
include:
Infectious
diseases are the second leading cause of death worldwide,
accounting for over 13 million deaths (25% of all deaths worldwide)
in 1999. The economic impact of infectious diseases is also
great, with an annual cost in excess of $120 billion. Twenty
well-known diseases - including tuberculosis (TB), malaria,
and cholera - have reemerged or spread geographically since
1973, often in more virulent and drug-resistant forms. At
least 30 previously unknown disease agents have been identified
since 1973 - including HIV, Ebola, and hepatitis C - for which
no cures are available.
An
estimated 61 million Americans have cardiovascular diseases,
35 million of whom are younger than 65 years of age. High
blood pressure affects 50 million Americans. More than 12
million Americans have coronary heart disease, 4.7 million
have congestive heart failure, 4.5 million have stroke, and
2 million have peripheral vascular diseases. Nearly 41 percent
of all deaths in 1998 in the U.S. were attributed to cardiovascular
diseases. Heart disease, alone, is America's No. 1 killer
and stroke is the No. 3 killer. Both are major causes of permanent
disability. The economic cost to the nation for cardiovascular
diseases in 2001 is projected to be $300 billion, including
$180 billion for health expenditures and $119 billion for
lost productivity.
Aging
- Ten years from now, 75 million Baby Boomers will begin to
turn 65. By 2050, the number of Americans over 65 will more
than double and the number of Americans over age 85 will increase
five-fold. With increasing age comes increasing risk of disease
and disability. According to a recent national survey, 60
to 70% of Americans age 60 and older have high blood pressure.
Radiographic evidence of osteoarthritis - the most common
form of chronic arthritis - is seen in 80% of the U.S. population
over age 70. One in two older women will have a fracture due
to osteoporosis. Late-onset Alzheimer's disease - the major
form of this disease - is responsible for up to 4 million
cases of dementia; by 2050, there could be 14 million cases.
Mental
Illness - The Surgeon General released a report
on January 3, 2001, announcing a "national crisis"
in children's mental health. In the United States, 1 in 10
children and adolescents suffer from mental illness severe
enough to cause impairment. The report calls for the further
development of scientifically proven prevention and treatment
services including developmental psychopathology, neural network
development, and pharmacogenetics.
Allergies
and asthma are major causes of illness
and disability in the United States. More than 50 million
Americans suffer from allergies and/or asthma. Although asthma
is a disease of low mortality, its economic costs are enormous,
totaling an estimated $14 billion in 1996. Health Disparities
- While the overall health of Americans has improved over
the past two decades, troubling disparities continue to persist
in the burden of illness and death experienced by African
Americans, Hispanics, Native Americans, Alaskan Natives, Asians,
and Pacific Islanders. The most striking disparities include
shorter life expectancy as well as higher rates of cardiovascular
disease, cancer, infant mortality, birth defects, asthma,
diabetes, stroke, sexually transmitted diseases, and mental
illness.
Social
and behavioral research - Six of the ten leading causes
of death are behaviorally based: obesity, smoking, violence,
substance abuse, HIV/AIDS, and unintentional injuries. Research
on topics such as basic sensory mechanisms, the effects of
different forms of stress on animal models, and the social
and cultural factors related to diabetes, hypertension, depression,
and cancer could lead to advances in many areas.
B.
Emerging Scientific Opportunities and the Changing Nature
of Research:
Thanks
to the previous investments in NIH, there are more exciting
basic and clinical science opportunities than ever before
in areas such as DNA research, genomics, molecular and cell
biology, immunology and auto-immunity, the neurosciences,
computational biology and computer science, bioengineering,
and imaging and information technologies.
On
June 26, 2000, leaders of the public Human
Genome Project and Celera
Genomics Corporation announced that both had successfully
completed the production of a working draft of the human genome.
Researchers expect to complete the first high-quality reference
of the human DNA sequence by 2003. Although not as refined
as the final version, the working draft completed in 2003
provides the community with sequence data covering most of
the genome and represents the raw data needed to find most
of the human genes.
Biological
science is increasingly based upon molecular genetics and
DNA and protein analysis. The understanding of many diseases,
ranging from cardiovascular disease, cancer and diabetes,
to psychiatric illness, needs to be pursued at the level of
genes and gene products. Although significant advances have
been made in working with large DNA fragments, new methods
and computational tools are needed for DNA analysis. The rapid
pace of progress in biotechnology and molecular biology presents
a challenge to pursue new computer and information science
advances to collect, analyze, and make available an ever-increasing
body of knowledge.
Advances
in computer modeling, x-ray crystallography, combinatorial
chemistry and robotics promise faster and cheaper drug discovery,
more precise and effective pharmaceuticals and new drugs for
diseases that have eluded treatment efforts.
Achievements
in the study of growth and tissue regeneration are setting
the stage for practical applications of tissue engineering,
permitting a new approach to the problem of replacing tissues
and organs damaged by disease or injury. In the field of dental
research, continued improvements in biomaterials have resulted
in composite resin polymers that are used for anterior restorations,
bonding agents, cements and sealants. In eye care, research
efforts are being directed toward the development of ocular
biomaterials such as intraocular lenses, corneal shields,
artificial tears and ocular drug delivery materials.
Explosive
progress is occurring against cancer. New technologies to
detect and diagnose cancer at an early stage are on the horizon.
Imaging devices and techniques are being developed and tested
that permit visualization of the cell with greater precision
than ever before. An exciting approach to cancer treatment
is immunotherapy, or treatments in which the patient's own
immune system is coaxed to recognize and eradicate cancer
cells.
In
sum, previous scientific advances have placed us on the threshold
of even more amazing scientific discoveries that promise more
treatments, diagnostics, and cures than ever before. In addition,
accelerated research progress and expanded opportunities in
medical science sparked by NIH funding have dramatically reshaped
the ways in which medical research is being conducted. Today,
much of the most exciting, cutting-edge research is interdisciplinary
in nature, requiring highly specialized teams of scientists
with backgrounds in multiple fields. By virtue of the larger
size and complexity of interdisciplinary research, it is more
costly. NIH is adapting to the challenges of interdisciplinary
research by implementing a variety of new funding mechanisms.
C.
Research Has Economic Benefits:
While
lives saved and human suffering prevented are the ultimate
justification for doubling the NIH budget, there is also a
dramatic economic return from our nation's investment in medical
research. According to a May 2000 Congressional Joint Economic
Committee (JEC) report, The
Benefits of Medical Research and the Role of the NIH,
public investment in NIH yields returns to the economy of
25% to 40% a year. Bottom-line returns to our economy can
be seen both in the greater productivity of longer-lived and
healthier citizens and the profits, employment and other economic
benefits generated by the biotechnology, medical technology
and pharmaceutical industries.
Economic
Productivity Recovered and Health Care Costs Saved - Cardiovascular
disease provides a dramatic example of the economic return
possible from a disease prevented, ameliorated or cured. According
the JEC, savings resulting from the reduction in cardiovascular
mortality and ensuing longevity and economic productivity
are estimated at $1.5 trillion a year. If one-third of this
reduction in disease and resulting economic benefit can be
attributed to medical research, the return on the research
investment could be $500 billion annually, or nearly 25 times
the size of the FY 2001 NIH budget.
A
1996 Wisconsin Association for Biomedical Research and Education
study
estimated that the direct cost savings from medical research
totals more than $100 billion dollars a year and that the
federal government's investment in bioscience is $62 per citizen,
while the benefits returned to each of us are worth $5,600.
Economic
Benefits - According to the JEC, the high-tech and
research-driven industries, including biotechnology and the
pharmaceutical industry, have contributed directly to one-third
of the nation's economic growth over the past decade. At the
same time, employment in high-tech industries has grown at
twice the rate of private-sector job creation as a whole,
and high-tech salaries are on average 82% higher than salaries
in other areas of the private sector. According to a 1999
Ernst and Young study of the biotechnology industry, biotech
employment grew by 9%, to 153,000 in 1998. In the same year,
product sales of $13.4 billion grew by 17% and more than 80
new biotechnology products were headed for market, while more
than 2500 were in clinical trials or earlier stages of development.
The JEC found that of the 21 most important drugs introduced
between 1965 and 1992, 15 were in part the result of federally-funded
research, and seven were the direct result of NIH research.
The success and prosperity of the U.S. pharmaceutical industry
has long depended upon NIH-supported science for "enabling
discoveries" and for training the skilled workers to
exploit new knowledge that leads to cures and therapies. The
revolutions in molecular biology and in genomics can only
strengthen this reliance.
The
economic returns that accrue from medical research, therefore,
provide an additional basis for supporting increased medical
research funding through NIH.
|