First published by the GEA in the September, 2001 Issue of "Academic Medicine," a series of articles that together make up a guide for reviewers
Sample Research in Medical Education (RIME) Paper Reviewer Reviews
A Tool for Reviewers: "Review Criteria for Research Manuscripts"
Bordage, Georges; Caelleigh, Addeane S.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):904-908
Introduction
How To Read "Review Criteria for Research Manuscripts"
Bordage, Georges; Caelleigh, Addeane S.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):909-910
Introduction
Review Process
Shea, Judy A.; Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Pangaro, Louis; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):911-914
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1
Selection and Qualities of Reviewers
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.; Penn, Gary
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):914-916
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1
Review Form
Steinecke, Ann; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):916-918
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1
Publication Decision
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):918-919
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1
Manuscript Revision and Final Editing
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):920-921
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1
Review Criteria
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):920-921
Review Criteria: Chapter 2
Problem Statement, Conceptual Framework, and Research Question
McGaghie, William C.; Bordage, Georges; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):923-924
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction
Reference to the Literature and Documentation
Crandall, Sonia J.; Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):925-927
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction
Relevance
Pangaro, Louis; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):927-929
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction
Research Design
McGaghie, William C.; Bordage, Georges; Crandall, Sonia; Pangaro, Louis
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):929-930
Review Criteria: Method
Instrumentation, Data Collection, and Quality Control
Shea, Judy A.; McGaghie, William C.; Pangaro, Louis
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):931-933
Review Criteria: Method
Population and Sample
McGaghie, William C.; Crandall, Sonia
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):934-935
Review Criteria: Method
Data Analysis and Statistics
McGaghie, William C.; Crandall, Sonia
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):936-938
Review Criteria: Method
Reporting of Statistical Analyses
Regehr, Glenn
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):938-939
Review Criteria: Results
Presentation of Results
Regehr, Glenn
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):940-942
Review Criteria: Results
Discussion and Conclusion: Interpretation
Crandall, Sonia J.; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):942-944
Review Criteria: Discussion and Conclusion
Title, Authors, and Abstract
Bordage, Georges; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):945-947
Review Criteria: Title, Authors, and Abstract
Presentation and Documentation
Penn, Gary; Steinecke, Ann; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):948-949
Review Criteria: Other
Scientific Conduct
Pangaro, Louis; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):950-951
Review Criteria: Other
Reviewer's Recommendation
Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):952-953
Reviewer's Recommendation: Chapter 3
Reviewer's Etiquette
Bland, Carole; Caelleigh, Addeane; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):954-955
Reviewer's Etiquette: Chapter 4
Conclusion
Bordage, Georges
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):956
Conclusion
Appendix 1: Checklist of Review Criteria
Task Force of Academic Medicine and the GEA-RIME Committee
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):958-959
Appendices
Appendix 2: Resources for Reviewers
Task Force of Academic Medicine and the GEARIME Committee
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):960-962
Appendices
Appendix 3: Sample Review Forms
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):963-975
Appendices