Skip to Content


Looking for Member-only Content?

opened lockSign in here to update your member information.


Create AAMC Account

1. Click sign in above
2. Enter personal information
3. Answer institutional identification questions
4. Answer AAMC questions

Forgot Login?

1. Click sign-in above
2. Click 'Forgot your password" or "Forgot your username"
3. Enter the email address you used to register




AAMC Mailing Lists

stamp on an envelope

AAMC mailing lists are available for sharing valuable information and resources with our member institutions and constituents.

A Guide for Reviewers

First published by the GEA in the September, 2001 Issue of "Academic Medicine," a series of articles that together make up a guide for reviewers

Sample Research in Medical Education (RIME) Paper Reviewer Reviews 

A Tool for Reviewers: "Review Criteria for Research Manuscripts"
Bordage, Georges; Caelleigh, Addeane S.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):904-908
Introduction

How To Read "Review Criteria for Research Manuscripts"
Bordage, Georges; Caelleigh, Addeane S.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):909-910
Introduction

Review Process
Shea, Judy A.; Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Pangaro, Louis; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):911-914
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1

Selection and Qualities of Reviewers
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.; Penn, Gary
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):914-916
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1

Review Form
Steinecke, Ann; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):916-918
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1

Publication Decision
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):918-919
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1

Manuscript Revision and Final Editing
Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):920-921
Review Process and Publication Decision: Chapter 1

Review Criteria
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):920-921
Review Criteria: Chapter 2

Problem Statement, Conceptual Framework, and Research Question
McGaghie, William C.; Bordage, Georges; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):923-924
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction

Reference to the Literature and Documentation
Crandall, Sonia J.; Caelleigh, Addeane S.; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):925-927
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction

Relevance
Pangaro, Louis; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):927-929
Review Criteria: Manuscript Introduction

Research Design
McGaghie, William C.; Bordage, Georges; Crandall, Sonia; Pangaro, Louis
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):929-930
Review Criteria: Method

Instrumentation, Data Collection, and Quality Control
Shea, Judy A.; McGaghie, William C.; Pangaro, Louis
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):931-933
Review Criteria: Method

Population and Sample
McGaghie, William C.; Crandall, Sonia
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):934-935
Review Criteria: Method

Data Analysis and Statistics
McGaghie, William C.; Crandall, Sonia
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):936-938
Review Criteria: Method

Reporting of Statistical Analyses
Regehr, Glenn
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):938-939
Review Criteria: Results

Presentation of Results
Regehr, Glenn
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):940-942
Review Criteria: Results

Discussion and Conclusion: Interpretation
Crandall, Sonia J.; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):942-944
Review Criteria: Discussion and Conclusion

Title, Authors, and Abstract
Bordage, Georges; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):945-947
Review Criteria: Title, Authors, and Abstract

Presentation and Documentation
Penn, Gary; Steinecke, Ann; Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):948-949
Review Criteria: Other

Scientific Conduct
Pangaro, Louis; McGaghie, William C.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):950-951
Review Criteria: Other

Reviewer's Recommendation
Shea, Judy A.
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):952-953
Reviewer's Recommendation: Chapter 3

Reviewer's Etiquette
Bland, Carole; Caelleigh, Addeane; Steinecke, Ann
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):954-955
Reviewer's Etiquette: Chapter 4

Conclusion
Bordage, Georges
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):956
Conclusion

Appendix 1: Checklist of Review Criteria
Task Force of Academic Medicine and the GEA-RIME Committee
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):958-959
Appendices

Appendix 2: Resources for Reviewers
Task Force of Academic Medicine and the GEARIME Committee
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):960-962
Appendices

Appendix 3: Sample Review Forms
Academic Medicine, September 2001,76(9):963-975
Appendices